Tim Burton and Johnny Depp, arguably one of the most magical director/actor combinations in film history, come together yet again in Sweeney Todd. At this point, someone buying a ticket for a Burton film, especially one with Depp in it, should have a pretty good idea of what they’re about to see. Even the fact that Sweeney Todd is a musical shouldn’t be too much of a surprise - there are musical numbers in Monkey Bone, The Nightmare Before Christmas (which Burton wrote but didn’t direct), Charlie and the Chocolate Factory, the list goes on. It is a bit strange, then, to have all the usual components of a classic Burton film with the exception of a Danny Elfman score. I realise that the film is an adaptation of a play, and all of the music had already been written for it by Stephen Sondheim, but I was a little disappointed in the lack of Elfman nonetheless. That’s not to say the music was bad, it’s just that I am a die hard Burton fan and as such have come to expect certain things. No one likes change.
Depp plays a man once banished from London by a judge who sought only to steal his beautiful young wife and baby daughter. When he returns from his exile, Sweeney Todd is no longer the mild mannered barber he once was, but a broken man out for ultimate revenge. A visit to his old home and barber shop leads him to his accomplice, Mrs. Lovett (Helena Bonham Carter), who is the most entertaining character in the film. Together they form a thriving business which suits both of their needs until, of course, Buy endep it all comes crashing down around them.
As I mentioned before, I am a big Tim Burton fan. I believe he will be remembered as an autour and master of his craft for his creativity and unique signature style. Maybe because all of that I was expecting too much. I won’t say I was disappointed in Sweeney Todd, but I was a bit underwhelmed. It just didn’t seem to reach its full potential. And perhaps it’s because this is an interpretation of a play and as such a little extra dramatic flair was in order, but the blood spewing forth from Todd’s victims was simply laughable. It was red-orange paint. Maybe that was intentional - maybe it was supposed to make the violent scenes more comical and easier to watch, but still. This is 2008 and horror movies are extremely popular. Realistic movie blood is not hard to come by.
Another problem I had with this film was the lack of a climax. When Todd isn’t plotting his revenge, he is mourning his long-lost daughter. Though she and her would-be suitor, a friend of Todd’s, are an important part of the plot, the film ends with that part of the story unresolved.
In its defence, though, Sweeney Todd does offer a dark film with not only murder and revenge central to its plot, but also voyeurism, incest, cannibalism, and perhaps just a touch of insinuated necrophilia. All of that, coupled with a good cast and a brilliant director, definitely redeems it a little. Though it could have been better, in someone else’s hands it almost certainly would have been worse.
Rating:
